Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Problems in Divorcing Conversion From Regeneration (16)



It is constantly affirmed by those who teach that sinners are born again before faith (BABF) or regenerated before faith, that sinners are totally passive in being saved, born of God, or regenerated. But, as I will show, this is not true.

Birth may refer to the moment of conception, the beginning of a human zygote, or it may refer to the time when a fetus exits or is "delivered" from the womb. Which of these is the focus in the Bible, whether it be physical birth or the new birth of the Spirit? As we will see, it is birth from the womb which is most widely the biblical meaning.

"Now when Jesus was born in Bethlehem" (Matt. 2:1)
"born this day in the city of David" (Luke 2:11)
"born of women" (Matt. 11:11)
"born from their mother's womb" (Matt. 19:12)

But we do have the word "conceived" to sometimes denote becoming pregnant as in "he was conceived in the womb" (Luke 2:21). We also see that in the KJV how the word "conceived" is sometimes used of the act of a woman giving birth as in Romans 9:10 and the words "and when Rebecca had conceived by one." In Genesis 4:1 we read where "Adam knew Eve his wife; and she conceived, and bare Cain, and said, I have gotten a man from the LORD." In James 1:15 James speaks of being conceived before being "brought forth" in the birth, but seems to contemplate both aspects in being begotten. We also see this in the birth of Christ.

"And, behold, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bring forth a son, and shalt call his name JESUS... And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God." (Luke 1:311,35)

We also see where it is the man who "begets" for he is the one who produces the seed (Grk. sperma). But, it is the woman who gives birth. But, we also see where God is said to do both. The only exception to this is in the protoevangelium where the promised Messiah and Redeemer would be peculiarly "the seed of the woman," and is said because the Redeemer would be born of a virgin.

When the Bible talks about being "born again," or "born of God," or "begotten of God," or "born of the Spirit," are we to think of conception or the birth proper? Some have thought that spiritual birth is just like physical birth and involves conception, development in the womb, and birth from the mother's womb. They view conception as regeneration proper, the time when the divine seed (I Peter 1:23) is deposited in a sinner, and see the time following that as a time when the begotten sinner is under conviction of sin and in the womb of darkness, and see the time of delivery from the womb as corresponding to the time when the regenerated sinner is brought to faith and repentance or converted. 

So, in this paradigm, there is both a father and a mother. If God or the Spirit is the Father (or sire), who is the mother? The old Hardshell Primitive Baptists held this view and I have often pointed this out to today's Hardshells and have asked them who is the mother? I get no answer. In the Bible the community of saints is viewed as the mother. In my post on the "Children of Zion" (See here) I write about this. Those who are born of God are also said to be born children of Zion. Paul spoke of a human being's creation by birth as being "of the man" but "by the woman." (I Cor. 11:11-12) I also cited these words from the Psalms:

"Glorious things are spoken of thee, O city of God. Selah. I will make mention of Rahab and Babylon to them that know me: behold Philistia, and Tyre, with Ethiopia; this man was born there. And of Zion it shall be said, This and that man was born in her: and the highest himself shall establish her. The LORD shall count, when he writes up the people, that this man was born there. Selah." (Psa. 87: 3-6)

"Let Israel rejoice in him that made him: let the children of Zion be joyful in their King." (Psa. 149: 2)

I also cited these words of the apostle Paul:

"But he who was of the bondwoman was born after the flesh; but he of the freewoman was by promise. Which things are an allegory: for these are the two covenants; the one from the mount Sinai, which genders to bondage, which is Agar. For this Agar is mount Sinai in Arabia, and answers to Jerusalem which now is, and is in bondage with her children. But Jerusalem which is above is free, which is the mother of us all." (Gal. 4: 23-26)

"Look unto Abraham your father, and unto Sarah that bare you: for I called him alone, and blessed him, and increased him. For the LORD shall comfort Zion" (Isa. 51: 2-3)

Since in spiritual birth believers have both a father and mother, we may say that the birth must involve the mother and that the focus is on birth from the womb and not on conception alone. 

Are Sinners Only Passive in Being Born Again?

We know that the child or zygote that is conceived by the union of the male seed and the female egg is passive in that creation. But, it is not true that the child in the womb is totally passive in its birth from the womb. This is what medical science tells us. So, those of the BABF view who say that children are totally passive in being born are not correct. There is a lot of literature on this for those who want to research it. That research says that when a baby’s lungs are fully developed, the baby releases specific proteins into the amniotic fluid. These proteins signal the mother’s body that the baby is ready to breathe air, helping initiate the hormonal cascade that starts labor. Under normal conditions the baby naturally aligns the shoulders with the pelvic outlet so that they fit through the narrowest space more easily, and they rotate at key points in the pelvis, following the shape of the birth canal instead of forcing against it, finding the path of least resistance, guided by the mother's uterine contractions.

We know that babies are active in the womb. They can kick and move around. They respond to sound, to music, and to the voice of others, particularly the mother. In Genesis 25:22-26 and Hosea 12:3 we read of the twins Jacob and Esau who "struggled together" in the womb of Rebekah. Jacob even came out after having grabbed Esau by the heel. John the Baptist responded to Mary's salutation as heard by his mother Elizabeth and even "leaped for joy." (Luke 1:41) So, this was a case of a child being active prior to its birth and this makes it highly probable that the baby in the womb is also active in preparing itself for birth.

Jesus told Nicodemus - "you must be born again." (John 3:1-8) Nicodemus responds: "how can a man enter the second time into his mother's womb and be born?" This shows that Nicodemus understands "born" in the sense of coming out of the womb. He also implies that he understands that a man can do something to be born a second time. "How can a man enter..." Jesus implies this also when he says "you must be born again." Why would Jesus say this to him if telling him this was useless because he could do nothing towards being born again but must simply wait and see if the Spirit will give him this new birth? Further, Nicodemus asked Jesus - "how can these things be?" Jesus answered that the Spirit does the work and that it occurs as a result of making believers in Jesus. In verses 14-17 Jesus answers Nicodemus's question further by saying:

"And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have eternal life. For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved."

Jesus explains that it is by looking to Christ by faith that a person obtains eternal life through a birth of the Spirit. The bitten dying Israelites looked to the serpent on the pole and by looking they were kept from perishing and were given new life. So, by looking to Christ a person obtains life, by a birth and by believing. Notice these words:

"And the Lord said unto Moses, Make thee a fiery serpent, and set it upon a pole: and it shall come to pass, that everyone that is bitten, when he looketh upon it, shall live." (Num. 21:8 kjv)

Those who looked up on the serpent on the pole received a new life by that act, were in a sense reborn. In Jesus's answer to the question of Nicodemus -- "how can these things be?" -- Jesus first said that it is the result of the work of the Spirit and then said it is the result of believing in Christ. He says eternal life, or spiritual life, comes by being born again and by believing. That being so, the question then becomes whether believing is passive or active. That it is an action of the sinner there can be no doubt. Of course the action is the result of the power of the Spirit and the gospel, as we have seen. As I have said, it may be compared to a person who desperately needs a heart transplant in order to live and recognizes this fact and then asks a heart surgeon to perform the transplant. The patient acted in asking and yet was passive in the operation.

Charles Spurgeon in his commentary on John chapter three and on what Jesus was teaching Nicodemus said (Available to read here; emphasis mine): 

"Now, perhaps, some of you will be saying, “How are we to be saved? If there is no salvation without the new birth, how can we obtain the new birth?” Listen. The same chapter which tells you of the mystery of regeneration, tells you of the simple way of salvation by faith in Christ. John 3:14-15. And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up: that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have eternal life. “Whosoever.” If you believe in Christ, you are born again. If you trust him, you have the new life. This simple way of salvation is not contradictory to the way of salvation by the new birth, it is the same thing stated in a form that we can comprehend... There are two great truths revealed here; the one is, that we must be born again, and the other is, that whosoever believeth in Christ is saved. Sometimes those two truths seem to come into conflict with one another. A man says, “You say to me, ‘Only believe, and you shall be saved;’ and then, by-and-by, you tell me that I must be born again. Are both these statements true?” Yes, they are both true, and they are both in this chapter. We have been reading about the necessity of regeneration, now comes the glorious freeness of the gospel of Christ. You must be born into a new life if you are to be saved; how are you to have that great blessing? There is life for a look at Jesus Christ lifted up upon the cross, and lifted up in the preaching of the gospel. Look to him, then; and, as surely as those who were bitten by the serpents in the wilderness were healed the moment that they looked at the serpent of brass, so surely shall every son or daughter of Adam, who gives a faith-look at the crucified Saviour, be saved at once and for ever...There is no contradiction here to what we have been reading. He that believes in Christ receives the new birth, receives eternal life, and thus by faith, he gets that which is essential to a sight and entrance into the kingdom of God."

I believe that Spurgeon is "spot on" in these words. In explaining to Nicodemus how he can be born again and obtain life, spiritual and eternal life, he told him to believe in him as the Messiah and Son of God. This shows that being born again a sinner is both acted upon and is active. 

Choosing to be Born?

I often hear those Calvinists of the BABF view argue that people do not choose to be born and so, they say, neither do they choose to be born again. But, in reply to this I say, first, that it is true that no person chooses to be born or created a physical human being, according to the Bible.  But, to say that this means that spiritual birth is the same is jumping to conclusions. That is because the person being born again already exists, has already been born and created as a human being. So, it is possible therefore for a person who has been born once to desire to be born or created anew. Lots of people would love to be born a second time and live life over again so as not to make the same mistakes, for instance. How many times have I said, like others, that I wish that I could go back to such and such a time in my life and to have made a different choice? In fact, in today's world of advanced science, people are able to be cloned, and are working on ways to obtain all a person's memories from the brain and incorporate them into the new cloned body. 

The same thing is often argued from the fact that not only do people not choose to be born but they also do not choose to be created or resurrected from the dead. But, we must not rely upon our human reasoning or what seems right or logical for our understanding of these mysteries. So Solomon said: "lean not upon your own understanding" (Prov. 3:5) and "there is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way of death." (Prov. 14:12) In reply to these arguments I have stated that we are not talking about someone who does not exist, who has not been created, who has never been born. We are talking about created people who desire to be newly created, to be, as it were, reborn, to obtain new life. In the Bible we see where David prayed for God to "create" in him a new heart. (Psalm 51:10) We also read where the apostle John said that spiritual life is obtained by believing in Christ. (John 20:31) In chapter fourteen I cited from Isaiah 51:1-3 where the Lord says "hear and your soul shall live." Jesus said that the spiritually dead first "hear the voice of the Son of God" and then are made alive by hearing. (John 5:25)

The apostle Peter said that people are "born again of incorruptible seed by the word of God which lives and abides forever." (I Peter 1:23) Abraham Booth (1734-1806), a leading 18th and 19th century Particular Baptist leader, rightly said:

"Regeneration must precede faith. This, though assumed as a certain fact:, may be justly doubted: for the page of inspiration does not warrant our supposing, that any one is born of God, before he believes in Jesus Christ; or, that regeneration is effected by the Holy Spirit, without the word of grace."

"But it is impossible for us to conceive of the mind being enlightened, of the conscience being relieved, of the will being regulated, and of the affections being purified by the word of truth, any further than it is believed. It may therefore be concluded, that regeneration is not, in order of time, prior to faith in Christ, and justification by him." ("Glad Tidings to Perishing Sinners," page 122) 

If the word of God or gospel is a means to bring about the new birth, then it can hardly be a means until it is heard and believed, as Booth rightly stated. This argument is no doubt a reason why many of the BABF folks deny that the gospel or word of God is a means in regeneration. Peter is saying that people are born again by believing the word of God. So, the question is whether people choose to believe, whether coming to Jesus and believing in him are acts of the will. 

Monday, November 16, 2026

My Wife's Exodus Into Paradise

As many readers know, I have several times asked for prayers for my wife Paulette. She has suffered from lung disease for many years but last evening she peacefully fell asleep in Jesus at Hospice house here in Monroe, N.C. She had a fall about ten days ago and another yesterday morning which precipitated her death. I believe it was an answer to prayer, the Lord keeping her from a prolonged agonizing death. I want to thank all who have prayed for her over the years. I will be arranging for her memorial service today and I will perhaps be writing a memorial of her life in the future. I do plan to be the chief speaker at her celebration of life service.

Stephen Garrett

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Futility of Arguing with Fools


"The way of a fool is right in his own eyes, 
But he who heeds counsel is wise." 
(Prov. 12: 15 nkjv)

I don't know about you but it wears me out to debate with a fool, especially a stubborn and willful one. It is an awful combination in a character to be both willfully ignorant or unwise and to be stubborn. It is also true in regard to those who "resist the truth" (II Tim. 3:8); And, among this group there are some fairly intelligent people. These folks will hold on to their opinions and views even when they are confronted with proof and evidence that overthrows those views. I have had to deal with all these kinds of stubborn fools. As I have shown in the past, the term "Hardshell" as in the Hardshell Primitive Baptists is a term designed to reflect those who stubbornly hold to their opinions no matter what evidence is brought to them that shows their error. I have found it laborious in laboring with such folks. 

I also have watched numerous videos of debates with liberal activists and politicians, the kind Charlie Kirk used to confront. These people are fools. You cannot debate with them for they ignore facts, do not answer questions, and use every trick in the book, as the Sophists of old did, to stubbornly avoid the stubborn facts. Instead of having a high level discussion of issues, they resort to name-calling, ad hominem attacks, verbal abuse, make use of red herrings, and every other fallacious practice. They will appeal to "experts" who agree with them, or appeal to the majority, appeal to tradition, not knowing these are fallacious arguments. 

Well did the wise king Solomon say: "If a wise man contends with a foolish man, Whether the fool rages or laughs, there is no peace." (Prov. 29: 9 nkjv) Indeed! There is no peace, no rest, no profit, in having a discussion of the issues with such fools. It is best to simply ignore and avoid them and go on. It is a waste of time. But, whether or not they are stubborn fools is not always immediately known. But, after a short time in debate with them you will begin to see that it is of no value to continue. So Solomon also advised: "Speak not in the ears of a fool: for he will despise the wisdom of thy words." (Prov. 23: 9 kjv)

Sometimes we should simply not answer a fool, but sometimes we should. So Solomon also said: "Do not answer a fool according to his folly, Lest you also be like him. Answer a fool according to his folly, Lest he be wise in his own eyes." (Prov. 26: 4-5 nkjv) So, which is it? Do we answer a fool or not? Solomon says yes and no, depending on who the fool is and the context. What Solomon means is that we should not respond to a fool by speaking the same way he speaks; otherwise, you become a fool like he is. However, he should be responded to so that he will not think he is correct, wiser than you, or won the argument. His conceit needs to be addressed. And sometimes he needs to be fed from his own spoon, so to speak.

Barry York wrote a good article on this topic (See here). He wrote (emphasis mine):

"To know how to deal with a fool, you first have to recognize him (being sure to check the mirror in the process!). The Bible gives us a ready description, especially in the book of wisdom known as the Proverbs. A fool does not fear the Lord or receive counsel, but delights in following his own ways and resisting correction (Prov. 1:7, 22; He is prone to angry outbursts (12:16; 14:17; 29:11). Such persons cannot control their mouths, babbling and arguing to their own ruin (10:10, 14; 18:7). This trait caused Solomon to muse like he was starting a bad joke, "A fool's lips walk into a fight" (18:6). A fool is as unproductive as paralyzed legs (26:7), as hurtful as a drunken archer (26:10), and as grossly predicable as a dog going back to its own vomit (26:11)."

He then wrote:

"Avoid fools whenever possible. We are clearly told to "leave the presence of a fool" in the Scriptures (14:7). For "a companion of fools will suffer harm" (13:20)." He also cited Solomon who also said: "let a man meet a she-bear robbed of her cubs rather than a fool in his folly" (Prov. 17:12). 

"Meet them with silence...usually. One cannot get much more direct than saying, "Do not speak in the hearing of a fool, for he will despise the good sense of your words" (23:9). How many talk shows would be canceled if that proverb was universally applied? Since fools are prone to argue, why give them the satisfaction (see 29:11)?"

"Let them bear their due punishment. Though fools despise correction, that does not mean they should be spared it. "Condemnation is ready for scoffers, and beating for the backs of fools" (19:29). Punishment just comes with the fool's territory. "A whip for the horse, a bridle for the donkey, and a rod for the back of fools" (26:3)."

"Suffer Fools Gladly"

To "suffer fools gladly" means to patiently, kindly, or tolerantly put up with people you consider foolish, slow, or annoying. However, the phrase is almost always used in the negative to describe a no-nonsense, impatient, or blunt person who has zero tolerance for incompetence, laziness, or foolish behavior. The phrase comes from the King James Version of the Bible (2 Cor. 11:19), where the Apostle Paul wrote: "For ye suffer fools gladly, seeing ye yourselves are wise." 

Paul said this sarcastically, and pointed out the irony in the Corinthian believers boasting of their superior wisdom and yet tolerated fools, false teachers. A wise man or woman will not "give place to" fools. The phrase "give place to" is used several times in the Bible, as when Paul said: "Neither give place to the devil" (Eph. 4:27). We are not to give the devil or fools room or opportunities to spew their foolishness and their lies and deception. 

Jesus often called perverters of the word of God "fools" and he always told them why they were such. Paul also called such people fools. So the Lord said of the false prophets -- "the prophet is a fool." (Hosea 9:7)

"See then that you walk circumspectly, not as fools but as wise." 
(Eph. 5:15 nkjv)

Friday, November 13, 2026

Problems in Divorcing Conversion From Regeneration (15)


"The hearing ear and the seeing eye, The Lord has made them both." 
(Proverbs 20:12 nkjv)

It is often argued by the born again before faith (BABF) folks that regeneration, rebirth, or quickening, is God's giving ears to hear or eyes to see, i.e. giving ability to hear and see, while conversion, or faith and repentance, are the actual hearing and seeing. So, the "opening of the eyes," the "opening of the ears," and the "opening of the heart" denote conversion and not regeneration. What can we say about that?

I am certain that regeneration or its cognates correspond to a person actually seeing, actually hearing or listening, actually being opened to accepting the gospel and the Christ proclaimed therein. A man is not spiritually alive until he has seen and believed in Christ, until his eyes have been opened so as to see and understand, and until his ears have been opened so as to actually hear Christ in the sense of being convicted of the truth of what he has heard.

The question as to whether an ability to believe and be converted must precede actual believing is an important one. Those Classical Arminians who believe in "total depravity" or inability, such as John Wesley, teach that God gives ability via "prevenient (or preceding) grace" via hearing the gospel and that this grace is able to overcome natural depravity so that a sinner may then freely accept or reject Christ. Many Calvinists today, especially among the BABF folks, totally reject any kind of prevenient grace, though others, like the older Calvinists, as Charles Spurgeon, and as I, believe in it, though not exactly as Wesley nor as the Catholics. (See my ongoing series on "Prevenient Grace"). The Puritan Calvinists believed that there were preparations for regeneration, men like William Perkins, John Owen, Stephen Charnock, etc.  So Owen wrote:

"I shall, therefore, in general, refer the whole work of the Spirit of God with respect unto the regeneration of sinners unto two heads:— First, That which is preparatory for it; and, secondly, That which is effective of it. That which is preparatory for it is the conviction of sin; this is the work of the Holy Spirit, John xvi. 8." ("Owen - Regeneration is Salvation"; here)

The older more sound Calvinists in the time of the Reformation and into the seventeenth century rejected the idea that God first gives an ability to believe prior to being saved and rather taught that the power to believe came through the Spirit operating through the word at the moment of coming to faith in Christ.

Owen wrote further (highlighting mine):

"First, The work of conversion itself, and in especial the act of believing, or faith itself, is expressly said to be of God, to be wrought in us by him, to be given unto us from him. The Scripture says not that God gives us ability or power to believe only,—namely, such a power as we may make use of if we will, or do otherwise; but faith, repentance, and conversion themselves are said to be the work and effect of God. Indeed, there is nothing mentioned in the Scriptures concerning the communicating of power, remote or next unto the mind of man, to enable him to believe antecedently unto actual believing. A “remote power,” if it may be so called, in the capacities of the faculties of the soul, the reason of the mind, and liberty of the will, we have given an account concerning; but for that which some call a “next power,” or an ability to believe in order of nature antecedent unto believing itself, wrought in us by the grace of God, the Scripture is silent." 

"But it will be objected, “That every thing which is actually accomplished was in potentia before; there must, therefore, be in us a power to believe before we do so actually.” Ans. The act of God working faith in us is a creating act: “We are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus,” Eph. ii. 10; and he that is in Christ Jesus “is a new creature,” 2 Cor. v. 17. Now, the effects of creating acts are not in potentia anywhere but in the active power of God; so was the world itself before its actual existence. This is termed potentia logica, which is no more but a negation of any contradiction to existence; not potentia physica, which includes a disposition unto actual existence. Notwithstanding, therefore, all these preparatory works of the Spirit of God which we allow in this matter, there is not by them wrought in the minds and wills of men such a next power, as they call it, as should enable them to believe without farther actual grace working faith itself. Wherefore, with respect to believing, the first act of God is to work in us “to will:” Phil. ii. 13, “He worketh in us to will.” Now, to will to believe is to believe. This God works in us by that grace which Austin and the schoolmen call gratia operans, because it worketh in us without us, the will being merely moved and passive therein. That there is a power or faculty of believing given unto all men unto whom the gospel is preached, or who are called by the outward dispensation of it, some do pretend; and that “because those unto whom the word is so preached, if they do not actually believe, shall perish eternally, as is positively declared in the gospel, Mark xvi. 16; but this they could not justly do if they had not received a power or faculty of believing.”

These words of John Owen refute the Wesleyan or Catholic idea of prevenient grace and also the BABF idea, for both these views require that God first gives ability to believe prior to believing. Obadiah Holmes (1606-1682), associate Baptist minister of John Clark, and pastors of probably the oldest Baptist Church in America, said the following in his written confession "The Last Will and Testimony of Obadiah Holmes":

"I believe that no man can come to the Son but they that are drawn by the Father to Him, and they that come He will in no wise cast away. I believe none has power to choose salvation or to believe in Christ, for life is the gift only of God." (As cited by me and elder Michael Ivey here and here)

Holmes agrees with Owen in that, prior to believing, no one has power to believe. But, if regeneration gives that power, and if regeneration precedes faith, then a power to believe precedes faith. Prior to believing a sinner has no power to believe; Rather, coming to believe is the result of a power outside of the sinner, being 1) "the working of his (God) almighty power" (Eph. 1:19), and 2) "the gospel which is the power of God unto salvation." (Rom. 1:16) Here is how that happens according to the apostle Paul:

-- "our gospel did not come to you in word only, but also in power, and in the Holy Spirit" (I Thess. 1:5) 

-- "And my speech and my preaching were not with persuasive words of human wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power, that your faith should not be in the wisdom of men but in the power of God." ( I Cor. 3: 4-5 nkjv)

The instant this divine power was exerted on a sinner to make him believe, he believed. We see this affirmed in Luke's words in the Book of Acts where he wrote: "And the hand of the Lord was with them, and a great number believed and turned to the Lord." (Acts 11:21 nkjv) By the "hand of the Lord" we are to understand divine power. 

Those of the BABF view tell us that God first gives spiritual eyes and ears (which is a giving of spiritual ability) and then the ones so gifted will believe, and among those who teach this there are some who say that there may be a gap in time between being given eyes and ears (which they call regeneration or being born of God) and the actual seeing and hearing truth or Christ with those eyes and ears. When I was a Hardshell Baptist and Hyper Calvinist I often heard their ministers say about Acts 26:18 and Jesus's commission to Paul to "open the eyes" of lost Gentiles -- "he sent him to open their eyes, not to give them eyes." They said this because they do not believe that God uses preachers or any human being as an instrument in the salvation of sinners. Therefore they cannot interpret that text as affirming that Paul was being sent to be a means in effecting the eternal salvation of sinners. Here is the text in question:

"I will deliver you from the Jewish people, as well as from the Gentiles, to whom I now send you, to open their eyes, in order to turn them from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan to God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins and an inheritance among those who are sanctified by faith in Me.’" (Acts 26: 17-18 nkjv)

It is quite obvious to any unbiased mind that Jesus is sending Paul to preach the gospel and thereby to be the means or instrumental cause of their salvation which would include initial salvation, and which is regeneration, or new birth, or being quickened from being dead in trespasses and sins. The several items to be effected by Paul's preaching show this to be so, namely, 

1) eyes being opened (which denotes illumination or enlightenment) 
2) turned from darkness to light
3) turned from the power of Satan to God
4) receive forgiveness of sins
5) receive an inheritance among the sanctified by faith

To open the eyes is what occurs in conversion and regeneration. Paul speaks of "the eyes of your understanding (or heart)" in Ephesians 1:18 (kjv). In Psalm 19:8 the word of God is said to enlighten the eyes. Enlightenment is part and parcel of what it means to be regenerated, born again, or quickened. So wrote the apostle Paul:

"For it is the God who commanded light to shine out of darkness, who has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ." (II Cor. 4:6 nkjv)

This text has almost universally been understood to be a description of what happens when a sinner is saved, born again, regenerated, or quickened. It shows that enlightenment is what is essentially involved in being saved or born again. It is a coming out of darkness and into the light. This involves coming to saving knowledge, "to give the light of the knowledge." When the apostle Paul describes born again people in Hebrews 6:6 he mentions several things, and the first on the list is that they have been "once for all enlightened," along with having "tasted of the heavenly gift" and "the good word of God" and of the "powers of the age to come," and had "become partakers of the Holy Spirit."  

To have one's eyes opened is to have been enlightened, to have come out of the darkness of ignorance and into the light of truth.

The words "he who has ears to hear, let him hear" are found multiple times in Matthew, Mark, and Luke (such as Matthew 11:15, Matthew 13:9, and Mark 4:9) and appears at the end of each of the seven letters to the churches in Revelation 2 and 3. 

Those of the BABF view will argue that by those words Jesus means "he who has ears to hear, or he who has the ability to hear spiritually by regeneration, let him hear." They will sometimes speak of Christ giving "spiritual ears" and "spiritual eyes" in regeneration, but there is no such thing. Regeneration does not add any new faculties to a man. Even most BABF teachers agree. They perhaps mean the ability to hear and see in a spiritual way is what is given in giving "spiritual ears and eyes." However, that is not what Christ meant when he said "whoever has ears let him hear." By these words we see that people choose whether they hear with their ears, that is why Christ says "let him hear." 

Some who have ears do not employ them in listening to the wise and to what is truth, but rather "turn their ears away from the truth, and be turned aside to fables." (II Tim. 4:4 nkjv) Even in everyday speaking we hear people say "you have ears don't you?" Or, "you have a brain don't you?" Or, "you have eyes, see for yourself." Etc. This is what Jesus said in Mark 8: 18: "Having eyes, do you not see? And having ears, do you not hear?" The people Jesus spoke about in the text in the heading are described as having ears and eyes but have quit listening and have closed their eyes and therefore they are not healed.

The command of the Lord to all who have ears to "hear" (listen or pay attention) is not addressed to only those who have been quickened but is addressed to all who have ears or the ability to receive the divine command. We see this in these words of the Lord: “Hear, you deaf; And look, you blind, that you may see." (Isa. 42:18 nkjv) These words are addressed to God's servant and messenger, to Israel. He says further: "Seeing many things, but you do not observe; Opening the ears, but he does not hear.” (vs. 20) Notice that they "see many things" so they are not without the faculty of sight, but they chose not to "observe." They were focusing on the wrong things, just as people are doing today. They even at times opened their ears but they did not hear, meaning they were but half or barely listening. Parents and teachers often see this in their children and students. 

On these verses John Gill, the one who had Hyper Calvinistic leanings, wrote the following in his best selling commentary (emphasis mine):

"the purport of the exhortation is, that they would make use of their external hearing and sight, which they had, that they might attain to a spiritual hearing and understanding of divine things; "for faith comes by hearing, and hearing the word of God", Romans 10:17 to hear the Gospel preached, and to look into the Scriptures, and read the word of God, are the means of attaining light and knowledge in spiritual things; and these are within the compass of natural men, who are internally deaf and blind."

All men who can hear are commanded to hear the Lord and his word; And, by "hearing" is meant not only to receive the sound of the words but to give attention to them, to listen attentively, to not be distracted. Many speakers have become frustrated with those not paying attention and have said -- "you are not hearing me" or have said "give me your undivided attention." 

In the preceding chapter I called attention to Isaiah 55: 1-3 and the Lord's saying "hear, and your soul shall live." The Father in heaven said about his Son Jesus - "hear (or listen) to him." (recorded in Matt. 17:5, Mark 9:7, and Luke 9:35). Certainly this is true to every person who hears about Jesus and what he said. When people do so, Christ says to them -- "But blessed are your eyes, for they see: and your ears, for they hear." (Matt. 13: 16 kjv)

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Problems in Divorcing Conversion From Regeneration (14)


Where Is Regeneration in John Six?

"All that the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will by no means cast out." (John 6: 37 nkjv)

"44 No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him; and I will raise him up at the last day. 45 It is written in the prophets, ‘And they shall all be taught by God.’ Therefore everyone who has heard and learned from the Father comes to Me. 46 Not that anyone has seen the Father, except He who is from God; He has seen the Father. 47 Most assuredly, I say to you, he who believes in Me has everlasting life. 48 I am the bread of life. 49 Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, and are dead. 50 This is the bread which comes down from heaven, that one may eat of it and not die. 51 I am the living bread which came down from heaven. If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever; and the bread that I shall give is My flesh, which I shall give for the life of the world.” (John 6: 44-51 nkjv)

"But there are some of you who do not believe.” For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were who did not believe, and who would betray Him. And He said, “Therefore I have said to you that no one can come to Me unless it has been granted to him by My Father.” (John 6: 64-65 nkjv)

Those who teach that sinners are born again before faith (BABF), regenerated or quickened from spiritual death before faith, tell us that the "drawing" of the Father in the above text is regeneration and the "coming" of the sinner to Christ is conversion or coming to Christ in repentance and faith. But, this is wrong for several reasons. 

First, such a view says that sinners are born again before they come to Christ, which coming to Christ is universally agreed to be equated with believing in Christ. However, if the coming to Christ is both a sinner's conversion and regeneration, his coming to have spiritual life, then 1) the things mentioned as preceding that coming and are the causes of that coming, 2) then we have proved that regeneration cannot be defined as the first initiatory act that God does towards causing sinners to come to Christ. In the above words of John chapter six we see the following things that are done by the Father prior to and causing a sinner's coming to Christ. They are:
 
1) drawing, 
2) communicating or speaking, 
3) teaching, 
4) granting. 

What is the result of having come to Jesus? 

Spiritual life is obtained by coming to Jesus Christ, as Jesus said to those who were spiritually dead: “But you are not willing to come to Me that you may have life." (John 5:40 nkjv) Since that is true, then no one has spiritual life until he has come to Jesus. Coming to Jesus is a coming out of death and a coming to life, just as Lazarus who came to life when Jesus said "Lazarus, come forth." As a result "Lazarus came forth." (John 11: 43-44) As I have pointed out many times, "come" and "came" are verbs in the active voice, showing that Lazarus did the coming and was active in it. He no doubt passively heard the words of the Lord but he was the one who did the coming. His quickening cannot be defined by the cause of it alone, i.e. the words spoken by Jesus to him, but must include the effect, which was Lazarus actually coming forth from the state of death. 

Just as a branch is alive by its union with the vine, so Jesus said that he is the vine and believers are the branches (John 15: 1-8) and the branches are alive by being in the vine. Being unconnected to Christ, "the true vine," means death. So, how does one get into Christ the Vine and thus possess life? It is by coming to Christ and receiving him as Lord and Savior. Christ said that he is "the way, the truth, and the life" (John 14:6), so, in order to obtain life one must come to him for it. It is by being "in Christ Jesus" (I Cor. 1:30) that a person is, according to that text, 1) made wise unto salvation, 2) declared righteous and justified, and 3) made holy in sanctification. 

People are in Christ by a penitent faith that "works by love." Christ, as Paul said, "dwells" in people's hearts "by faith." (Eph. 3:17) Jesus also said: "If a man love me, he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and make our abode with him." (John 14: 23 kjv)

Some other verses that speak of coming to Christ and coming to God are these:

"Therefore He is also able to save to the uttermost those who come to God through Him, since He always lives to make intercession for them." (Heb. 7:25 nkjv)

"But without faith it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him." (Heb. 11:6 nkjv)

"As you come to him, the living Stone..." (I Peter 2: 4 niv)

Until a sinner comes to Christ, he has not reached Christ, and has not become one with him. Christ and the unbeliever are not with each other. There is no union or communion. In being saved, or born again, or regenerated, or quickened, there is a coming together of Christ and the sinner. Christ comes to the sinner and the sinner comes to Christ, just as two "come together" in marriage and in the sexual union (See Matt. 1:18). 

In the old testament we see where Yahweh calls upon poor sinners to "come" to him in order to have divine or spiritual life and have it abundantly, saying: 

“Ho! Everyone who thirsts, Come to the waters; And you who have no money, Come, buy and eat. Yes, come, buy wine and milk Without money and without price. Why do you spend money for what is not bread, And your wages for what does not satisfy? Listen carefully to Me, and eat what is good, And let your soul delight itself in abundance. Incline your ear, and come to Me. Hear, and your soul shall live; And I will make an everlasting covenant with you— The sure mercies of David." (Isaiah 55: 1-3 nkjv)

There are many active voice verbs in these words. The ones addressed "come," "buy," "eat," "spend," "listen," "delight," "incline" the ear, "hear," and "live." They are not totally passive in obtaining the divine life with all the good things that come with it. Also, inclining the ear and hearing and heeding God's gracious call precedes as a necessary condition for obtaining life. In the words of John 6:45 -- "heard and learned from the Father comes to Me," the verbal participles "having heard" and "having learned" are in the active voice and therefore further show that the sinner is not totally passive in all that is involved in his regeneration. He is both acted upon (passive) and he acts (active). God does the drawing but the sinner does the coming. Further, you cannot say a sinner has been drawn until he has been drawn to or reached the point he is being drawn to by the Father, which point is Christ. 

The above verses on coming to God by faith in Hebrews and First Peter say that salvation is what is obtained by coming, and salvation involves being quickened. Jesus's final words in the last book of the Bible said:

"And the Spirit and the bride say, “Come!” And let him who hears say, “Come!” And let him who thirsts come. Whoever desires, let him take the water of life freely." (Rev. 22:17 nkjv)

So, not only was Yahweh calling out to sinners to come to him and have life by hearing and heeding his call, but so did Jesus who was Yahweh incarnate, as we have seen. In the above text Jesus basically says that he, the Spirit, and the bride are also saying to sinners "come." It is addressed to all who hear the gracious call, to all who are thirsty, and who desire salvation from that thirsty condition. It is the same call he gave during his life on earth when "Jesus stood on the last day, that great day of the feast, and cried out, saying, “If anyone thirsts, let him come to Me and drink." (John 7:37) It is similar to the call he made in Matthew chapter eleven where he said:

"Come to Me, all you who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me, for I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you will find rest for your souls." (11:28-29 nkjv) 

Contrary to what the Hardshell Baptists teach, the ones described as parched, thirsty, beaten down with heavy loads of guilt and burdens, are not saved people but unsaved, the description is not one of salvation but of a perishing condition.

I want to add a side note or commentary on Revelation 22: 17. While studying this text in conjunction with this series I focused on the question of who is the one speaking in the text, a question I had never considered before. Is it Christ, John, or "the Spirit and the bride"? I looked at several commentaries and none addressed this question. I did read where Pulpit Commentary wrote: "These words are best understood as uttered by the writer." I rather think it is the risen Lord Jesus. 

I then engaged in a back and forth discussion with Google AI and got the answer that it was the Spirit and the bride. I then told AI that such a view is wrong because it is the speaker who is telling us what the Spirit and bride said, speaking in the third person. AI then agreed. Then AI said that it was John who was speaking, which is a common view of many commentators who address the question. I then asked AI whether it was more likely that Christ was the one who was speaking since he was the one speaking in verse 16 and in verse 18 and there is no indication that John spoke in verse 17. I also asked AI whether the conjunction word "and" (Greek word "kai") which begins the verse may also mean "also." AI says yes. I asked, "does it not make more sense that Christ is saying "not only do I say 'come' but also the Spirit and the bride say 'come'""? AI then agreed completely and said (emphasis mine):

"If Jesus is the one narrating what the Spirit and the Bride say, it creates a seamless monologue: 

Unity of Voice: 

You don't have to imagine the "camera angle" switching from Jesus in heaven back to John or the Church on earth. Jesus is simply delivering the final invitation Himself, citing the Spirit and the Bride to emphasize how urgent the invitation is. 

The Flow to Verse 18: In the very next verse (v. 18), the speaker says, "I warn everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book..." Many readers naturally feel that this solemn warning comes directly from the mouth of Christ. If Jesus is speaking in verse 17, the transition into verse 18 is completely unbroken."

I say all this because I want the reader to see how the call to all who hear the invitation, and all who thirst for relief from this sinful world, and all who desire the water that gives life, to take the water that is offered to them. There are four verbs or verbal participles in the text besides the verb "come." They are all in the active voice in the Greek. If this is an invitation or call to salvation, then it cannot be true that salvation is unconditional, nor that there is no action of the one being saved, regenerated, quickened, converted, etc. 

What Kind of Genitive?

The words "water of life" is a genitive of which there are several kinds, and the way the word is written in Greek does not tell you what kind it is. Only how the genitive is used in the text or context helps to determine the kind. Do the words mean "water that comes from life" (genitive of source)? That does not seem right. Do they mean "water that is life" (genitive of apposition)? That is very possible. Do they mean "water that brings life" (objective genitive)? That too is very possible and the likely right answer. This AI search result (here) for what Greek scholars say on this point can be looked at by the reader. I think it is very clear that it denotes water that is life giving and this idea can be conveyed through being an objective genitive or genitive of apposition. If that is true, then we see several things that precede obtaining spiritual life. We have already seen from John chapters Five and Six that life is obtained by coming to Christ and that four things the Father does precede the coming (Father's speaking, teaching, drawing, and granting (or giving). 

The "water of life" means the same as the "bread of life" (John 6:48-51) and the latter clearly means the bread which gives life. In verse 33 Christ says that the bread is what "gives life."

We have also seen that the sinner is not completely passive in being quickened from spiritual death. We also see where salvation involves a process and is not instantaneous. But, on this I will have more to say in the next chapters.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Does Helen Keller's Conversion Prove Faith Does Not Come By Hearing The Word of God?



Recently I had it argued to me that Helen Keller (1880-1968), the famous girl who became blind and deaf when she was 19 months old, and who was born in Alabama and taught to read braille by Anne Sullivan, shows via her "conversion" that people can come to faith in Christ without ever hearing anyone tell them about Christ. Before addressing that argument, let me first give the reader information about her supposed conversion.

Helen Keller did not experience a sudden, dramatic "conversion" to a traditional Christian denomination; rather, she stated that she had an innate, lifelong awareness of God and later formally embraced the mystical Christian teachings of Emanuel Swedenborg in her early teens.

To be aware or to believe that there is a god is no proof of having been saved. James made that clear when he said: "You believe that there is one God. You do well. Even the demons believe—and tremble!" (James 2: 19 nkjv) Lots of unsaved people believe in God or some god or gods. So Paul wrote:

"For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened. Professing to be wise, they became fools, and changed the glory of the incorruptible God into an image made like corruptible man—and birds and four-footed animals and creeping things." (Rom. 1:20-23 nkjv)

Here are unsaved people who believed in the existence of God as a Creator. Keller famously remarked later in life, "I always knew God was there, I just did not know his name," explaining that she sensed an underlying presence. But, that is not a sign of regeneration. Also, her sense that there was a god did not entail that she knew Jesus as Savior and Lord. 

Hardshell Baptists, because they are always intent on denying that one must hear the gospel or word of God in order to believe in Jesus, will sometimes argue that one may believe in Jesus by direct revelation apart from being told by a preacher or Christian layman who Jesus is, what he did, and how to be saved through him. However, that is simply against what is plainly declared by Paul in Romans chapter ten where he wrote:

“8 The word is near you, in your mouth and in your heart” (that is, the word of faith which we preach): 9 that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved. 10 For with the heart one believes unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation. 11 For the Scripture says, “Whoever believes on Him will not be put to shame.” 12 For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek, for the same Lord over all is rich to all who call upon Him. 13 For “whoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved.” 14 How then shall they call on Him in whom they have not believed? And how shall they believe in Him of whom they have not heard? And how shall they hear without a preacher? 15 And how shall they preach unless they are sent? As it is written: “How beautiful are the feet of those who preach the gospel of peace, Who bring glad tidings of good things!” 16 But they have not all obeyed the gospel. For Isaiah says, “Lord, who has believed our report?” 17 So then faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God." (vss. 8-17 nkjv)

After Helen Keller learned to communicate through her teacher, Anne Sullivan, her parents felt it was time for her to receive religious instruction. She was taken to Phillips Brooks, who told her simply about God and Jesus. So, she accepted the fact that God's name was Jesus and what Brooks told her. However, she did not know Jesus and what he had done prior to Brooks telling her. So, that fact shows that what Paul said is true. 

When Keller began to study the Bible for herself she accepted the teachings of Emanuel Swedenborg (which came to be known as Swedenborgianism). Helen Keller at that point found inner solace, or as she says, spiritual sight, and an understanding of the divine through Swedenborg's writings, writing an entire book about her faith (My Religion, later titled Light in My Darkness). She also became a Socialist.

Swedenborgianism rejects the traditional doctrine of the Trinity as three separate persons, teaching instead that God is one person in Jehovah / Jesus Christ. "Got Questions" web page (here) says this about the teachings of this sect per their founder:

"These writings include teachings such as: God has many names, depending on the beliefs/religion of the individual; the Holy Spirit is not God; the Trinity does not exist; Jesus Christ’s death did not atone for our sin; salvation comes by practicing what you believe, whatever religion it might be; the afterlife is spiritual, but dependent on how well you lived in your physical body."

Actually, Swedenborgianism is a pseudo Christian cult similar to the Christian Science cult and similar to Scientology. They deny the literal second coming of Christ. Swedenborg is similar to Joseph Smith, saying that he had experienced a death and resurrection, and had gone to heaven and returned so that he could tell others about the spiritual realm. He also taught, like the Mormons, that some married couples will live as married couples in heaven. They have other beliefs that are simply against what the Bible teaches. 

In conclusion I say that Helen Keller did not profess to believe in Jesus or the gospel until Brooks told her about him, and this is in agreement with what Paul taught in Romans chapter ten.

Yes, there is a revelation involved in being saved. The Father revealed to Peter that Jesus was the Christ the Son of the living God and not "flesh and blood." (Matt. 16: 16-17) Jesus, the Son of the Father, also is the one who reveals to men the Father, saying: "no one knows the Son except the Father. Nor does anyone know the Father except the Son, and the one to whom the Son wills to reveal Him." (Matt; 11: 27 nkjv)

But, neither of these revelations occurs apart from hearing information about the Father and Son. When people hear someone inform them about the Father and Son, it is the Father and Son, and the Holy Spirit too, who must open the eyes (or reveal) to see and accept that information as being true. Peter had been taught about a coming Messiah but he did not come to recognize Jesus as he until his eyes were opened to see it as true. The statement that Peter believed in Jesus by the Father's revealing it, and not by men, does not contradict what Paul said in Romans chapter ten. 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Problems in Divorcing Conversion From Regeneration (13)



One of the problems with the born again before faith (BABF) view is in its identifying the first thing that God does in leading to salvation as regeneration, thereby denying that there are any pre-regeneration or preparatory acts, steps, or means prior to salvation. Thus they see the very first "initiatory" act of God as being regeneration, denying that there is any prevenient grace (grace that precedes salvation). They often falsely charge others who deny the BABF view (among both Arminians and Calvinists) with denying that God is the one who initiates salvation rather than the sinner or any other man. Only the Pelagians would sometimes argue that the sinner initiates his own salvation. So, that is not the issue. It is a red herring. Rather, the question is whether there are any preparatory steps or means that occur prior to salvation and whether the means are always successful in actually saving or regenerating sinners, and why it is successful in some but not in others.

The Puritans were Calvinists who agreed with Calvin and Beza in denying that regeneration preceded faith and in affirming that there are preparatory things that occur prior to regeneration, and that these preparations are not salvation or evidences of salvation. I write at length about this in my ongoing series "Prevenient Grace." (began in April of this year; See archives) I have articles yet to add to this series in which I have numerous citations to make from Dr. Joel Beeke, expert on Puritan Calvinism, who cites extensively from the Puritans on their belief in things that must precede regeneration. The above book in the heading is a great source for such citations, with co-author Smalley.

Are there no preparations for being saved or regenerated? Are there no means thereunto, as the born again before faith (BABF) folks tend to deny? The Bible teaches that there are indeed things that generally occur prior to being saved, born again, or coming to faith in Christ. We may call these things preparations, steps, means, inducements, or graces of God.

Things God Does Prior To Salvation 
(including regeneration or new birth) 

1. God makes known the law and the gospel
2. The Father draws and pulls
3. The Father speaks to the heart
4. The Father teaches
5. God opens the eyes to see
6. God opens the ears to hear
7. God gets a sinner's attention by opening the heart 
8. God awakens sinners in regard to the things of God
9. The Spirit convinces sinners of sin and lost condition
10. God enlightens or informs sinners
11. God calls the sinner through the gospel
12. The Spirit influences hearts and minds

Those of the BABF view want to say that regeneration precedes all of these things. Doing so, however, makes the most wicked sinners and even unbelievers to be regenerated living children of God. It has also led to some of them becoming Universalists or almost so, saying, like the Hardshell Baptists, that only a small few are going to Hell. Many of the things listed above occur in the lives of many who are never saved, as we will see. On the other hand, the above things generally occur previously to regeneration in those who come to be saved. 

Many people experience influences from the Spirit and word of God but who are never saved. By "influence" I mean inducing, urging, impacting, persuading, swaying, coaxing, pressuring, or otherwise acting upon a person's thoughts and feelings. We see this influence operative in the preaching of Stephen the martyr. Stephen said the following in that sermon: "You stiff-necked and uncircumcised in heart and ears, you do always resist the Holy Spirit." (Acts 7: 51 nkjv) Resisting the Holy Spirit logically requires that the Spirit is actively exerting an influence, force, conviction, upon an individual prior to his being saved. In physics, resistance cannot exist without a counter-force; to resist the Spirit therefore implies that the Spirit is exerting a force or influence. A person cannot push back against divine influence or nudging unless that is present and operative on that person. 

Those of the BABF view and the Hyper Calvinists often resist (pun intended) acknowledging that the Spirit exerts influence unto salvation in any who are not eventually saved or in those not of the elect. So, rather than acknowledging this fact they will argue that this fact does not annul the truth of the doctrine of effectual calling or "irresistible grace" (which is true) and say that the words of Stephen simply show that it is the nature of dead sinners to so resist. That also is true, but it does not address the issue which says that the Spirit does exert influence on the hearts and minds of dead sinners for the purpose of showing them their need of salvation and of the way of salvation. The question is, does this influence precede salvation? And the answer is yes. The idea that sinners must first be saved or regenerated before they can be positively influenced by the Spirit is not biblical. 

In the book of Genesis we read where the Spirit of God was "striving" with those wicked people who all died in the flood as a judgment upon their sins. (Gen. 6: 3) These people are called "the world of the ungodly." (II Peter 2:5) What was the nature and purpose of this striving? This striving was done through the preaching of Noah. (I Peter 3: 19) John Gill, who is often accused of being a Hyper Calvinist (mostly a false charge) and of denying that the word or gospel of God was a means in effecting salvation (which is also false), said the following in his commentary on Genesis 6:3:

"...this is to be understood of the Holy Spirit of God, as the Targum of Jonathan, which agrees with 1 Peter 3:18 and to be thus interpreted; that the Spirit of God, which had been litigating and reasoning the point, as men do in a court of judicature, as the word signifies, with these men in the court, and at the bar of their own consciences, by one providence or by one minister or another, particularly by Noah, a preacher of righteousness, in vain, and to no purpose; therefore, he determines to proceed no longer in this way, but pass and execute the sentence of condemnation on them..."

It is therefore an error to say that regeneration must be defined as the first initiatory act of God intended to effect regeneration. Gill's successor was first John Rippon and then Charles Spurgeon. Here is what Spurgeon wrote on preparations that precede regeneration in "Things that Accompany Salvation" (See here; emphasis mine):

"3. We will begin, then, with the advance guard that has accompanied Salvation or rather gone before it. We shall then come to those who immediately precede it, and then we shall notice those who accompany it by its side, and conclude by noticing the rearguard attending upon this Salvation of our God."

Spurgeon did not believe that the first act of God in initiating salvation was salvation, for he believed in preparations and in prevenient grace. He said further:

"For, before he can be made whole, he must be spiritually killed, the sword must pierce him, and must slay all his selfishness before he can be brought to the Lord Jesus. Then another body of them carry with them axes, with which they cut down the thick trees of our pride and abase the goodly cedars of our righteousness. There are with them those that fill up the wells with stones, and break up all the cisterns of our carnal sufficiency, until we are driven to despair, having all our hopes despoiled. Then come those who, with brazen trumpets, or with trumps of ram’s horns—like those who once razed Jericho level with the ground—do blow a blast, so shrill and dread, that the sinner thinks that even the yells of hell itself could not be more terrible. Then come those who with lances pierce the spirit through and through; and in the rear are the ten great guns, the artillery of the law, which, perpetually fire upon the wounded spirit until it does not know what it is, nor what it does...Before a man can be truly converted, he must suffer great agony of spirit; all our self-righteousness must be laid level with the ground, and trampled like the miry streets. Our carnal hopes must, every one of them, be cut in pieces, and our refuges of lies must be swept away with the hail of God’s anger. The law of God will appear terrible to the sinner when he is first convicted of sin...This Thundering Legion always precedes Salvation. More or less of terrors every man must feel before he is converted. Some have less, some have more; but there must be some measure of this terrible law work in the soul, or else Salvation is not come to a man’s house...unless this broken heart has come within your bosom you cannot be made partakers of Christ. The heart must first be pounded in the mortar of conviction, and beaten in pieces with the pestle of the law, or else it never can receive the grace of the Comforter in all its plenitude. Are you broken hearted today? Are you sorrowful at this very hour? Be of good cheer, Salvation is not far behind. When there is once a broken heart there is mercy very near. The broken heart is the prelude of healing. He who kills will make whole; he who wounds will bind up; he who struck will cure. God is looking on you with love, and will have mercy upon you." 

In the list of things that precede regeneration I put hearing the gospel or word of God number one. The only ones who will deny that the gospel is a means in regeneration are the Hardshell Baptists and the Paedobaptists among the Presbyterians who teach that the children of believing parents are regenerated in infancy when baptized and in that case the gospel was not a means. The Bible clearly teaches that the preaching of the gospel is a means in the new birth. Peter said believers have been "born again by the word of God" (I Peter 1:23) and James said that "he (God) has begotten us with the word of truth" (James 1:18) and Paul said "I have begotten you through the gospel" (I Cor. 4:15). Paul is also clear about this in his letter to the Romans, saying:

"13 For “whoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved.” 14 How then shall they call on Him in whom they have not believed? And how shall they believe in Him of whom they have not heard? And how shall they hear without a preacher? 15 And how shall they preach unless they are sent? As it is written: “How beautiful are the feet of those who preach the gospel of peace, Who bring glad tidings of good things!” 16 But they have not all obeyed the gospel. For Isaiah says, “Lord, who has believed our report?” 17 So then faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God." (10:13-17 nkjv)

In the above list I also mentioned how the drawing and teaching of the Father precedes regeneration. On that I will enlarge upon in the next chapter. Concerning items five through nine I will say this for now. Those of the BABF view err when they argue that the giving of eyes and ears are regeneration and therefore precede the opening of the eyes and ears. They also argue that the "opening" of Lydia's heart, a prerequisite to her giving attention to the preaching of Paul and her believing the gospel, was her regeneration. This too is an error for her regeneration occurred either before Paul appeared to the group she was praying with or when she believed Paul's preaching. I wrote at length on the dispute over this issue in this post (here). I cited from Spurgeon who rightly saw the opening of Lydia's heart as a preparation for regeneration and not regeneration itself. I cited these words from him on that text (Acts 16:14):

"We do not well if we forget the prevenient providences which work before our conversion, to bring us unto that spot where God was pleased to manifest himself unto us." 

"Observe next, that in Lydia's case there was not only preventing providence, but there was also grace in a certain manner preparing the soul. The woman did not know the Saviour; she did not understand the things which make for her peace, yet she knew many truths which were excellent stepping-stones to a knowledge of Jesus." 

"She worshipped God; worshipped him in sincerity; worshipped him looking for the coming of the Messiah, Israel's consolation; and so her mind was prepared for the reception of the gospel. Doubtless, dear friends, in many of us there was a preparation for Christ before Christ came to us in quickening grace."

"Still, dear friends, we ought to ascribe all this preparatory work to sovereign grace, for grace—free favour does much in which no grace of effectual salvation is perceptible. I mean that before grace renews the heart there is grace preparing us for grace; grace may be setting the mind in activity, clearing us from prejudice, ridding us of a thousand infidel and sceptical thoughts, and so raising a platform from which divine grace conducts us into the region of the new life. Such was the case of Lydia, such is the case of many; providence and grace co-work before the effectual time is come." 

"...although the Lord opened the heart, Paul’s words were the instrument of her conversion. The heart may be opened, and willing to receive, but then if truth enter not, what would be the use of an open door? But God always takes care to open the heart at a time when the messenger of mercy shall be going by, that the heart may give him admittance." ("Lessons from Lydia’s Conversion" - here)

A man cannot be said to have been regenerated, born again, or quickened until he has actually seen with his opened eyes and actually heard with his opened ears and actually received with his opened heart. I will have more to say on these things in upcoming chapters.

Monday, November 9, 2026

A Debater, Sophist, or Persuader?

Oftentimes when I have been arguing (that is not a bad word by the way) with others on some Bible doctrine or interpretation and I am leaving my opponent of the contrary view unable to answer an argument, I hear him say "I see why you are such a good debater." When I hear that I find myself trying to figure out what that means. Does he mean I am a good Sophist who simply knows how to win an argument even if it is defending what is not true? Or, does he mean I am a good persuader? I hope it is the latter, but oftentimes it is not, but is rather a way for the defeated opponent to deal with his cognitive dissonance and inability to meet the arguments or proofs that refute his view and a way to divert attention away from the argument that overthrows his viewpoint. 

All the great men of God in the Bible were great persuaders, people skilled in argumentation and debate. Why? Because they had God-given wisdom, and because they knew their subjects well. So we read these words of Jesus to his appointed ambassadors: "I will give you a mouth and wisdom which all your adversaries will not be able to contradict or resist." (Luke 21: 15 nkjv)

Jesus was the master who was able to refute every argument his adversaries brought to him. The apostle Paul was like his master in this regard. Anyone familiar with his apologetic writings will know this to be the case. 

Who can read the sermon of Stephen in Acts chapter seven and not see where he spoke with the kind of wisdom Jesus said he would give to his messengers, for Stephen's opponents, rather than rebutting his arguments took up stones to stone him. We see this today in those on the liberal, socialist, communist left who do not want to debate but simply want to kill or otherwise silence their opponents, as was the case in the murder of Charlie Kirk.

Scripture notes that Stephen's opponents "could not withstand (resist kjv) the wisdom and the Spirit with which he was speaking" (Acts 6:10), forcing them to resort to false accusations and murdering him. He made powerful arguments from scripture and reasoned logic that refuted his opponents. They should have opted to acknowledge their defeat and changed their minds and beliefs. 

Apollos is described as an eloquent man and "mighty in the Scriptures" (Acts 18:24) and he spoke with great fervor and "vigorously refuted the Jews in public, showing by the Scriptures that the Christ was Jesus" (Acts 18:28).

Of the apostle Paul's debates we read:

"1 Now when they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica, where there was a synagogue of the Jews. 2 Then Paul, as his custom was, went in to them, and for three Sabbaths reasoned with them from the Scriptures, 3 explaining and demonstrating that the Christ had to suffer and rise again from the dead, and saying, “This Jesus whom I preach to you is the Christ.” 4 And some of them were persuaded; and a great multitude of the devout Greeks, and not a few of the leading women, joined Paul and Silas." (Acts 17: 1-4 nkjv)

"After these things Paul departed from Athens, and came to Corinth...And he reasoned (dialegomai) in the synagogue every sabbath, and persuaded (peithō) the Jews and the Greeks." (Acts 18: 1,4)

"8 And he went into the synagogue and spoke boldly for three months, reasoning and persuading concerning the things of the kingdom of God. 9 But when some were hardened and did not believe, but spoke evil of the Way before the multitude, he departed from them and withdrew the disciples, reasoning daily in the school of Tyrannus. 10 And this continued for two years, so that all who dwelt in Asia heard the word of the Lord Jesus, both Jews and Greeks." (Acts 19: 8-10 nkjv)

Paul debated. Paul discussed. Paul argued. Paul persuaded. However, he did not quarrel, nor did he become bombastic, prideful, nor did he debate simply because he enjoyed verbal sparring, nor did he follow the rhetorical methods of the Sophists. In fact, Paul said much in his letters to the Corinthian Christians in condemnation of the tactics of the Sophists. (See this page here that gives some of my articles on this from my series "God's Elect or World's Elite?" which has its own blog; See link on this web page) I cited from a good book by Bruce W. Winter titled "Philo and Paul among the Sophists" which explored how the Apostle Paul interacted with and rejected the rhetorical and cultural influence of first-century Greek Sophists in Corinth. We have many Sophists today, being people who, for hire, try to win a debate for personal gain. We see them among lawyers in courtrooms where an attorney is not trying to find the truth but to help his client win a case, whether the client is right or wrong. We also see it in politicians.

Believers are told to "always be prepared to give an answer (Greek "apologia", apology or rational defense) to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect." (1 Peter 3:15) Believers are also warned to "avoid foolish controversies and genealogies and arguments and quarrels about the law, because these are unprofitable and useless." (Titus 3:9) Paul told Timothy that a servant of the Lord "must not be quarrelsome, but must be kind to everyone, able to teach, not resentful. Opponents must be gently instructed." (2 Tim. 2:24–25) He also warned against having an "unhealthy craving for controversy and for quarrels about words (logomachies), which produce envy, dissension, slander, [and] evil suspicions." (1 Tim. 6:4) 

Paul condemns "debate" (kjv) n Romans 1:29 and "debates" (plural) in I Corinthians 12:20, but by that word (Greek word "eris") is meant contention, strife, wrangling. It is translated as "contentions" (plural) in I Cor. 1:11). It is also translated by the word "variance" (Gal. 5:20) and "rivalry" (Phil. 1:15 in many translations) where Paul spoke of some who "indeed preaches Christ from envy and rivalry, but others from good will" (Phil. 1: 15 nkjv); And, LORD God speaks of such vicious wranglings when he said: "Indeed you fast for strife and debate, And to strike with the fist of wickedness." (Isa. 58:4 nkjv) It is the kind of debate where opponents "bite and devour one another" with their words. (Gal. 5:15) James spoke of this kind of unholy debate when he asked "Where do wars and fights come from among you? Do they not come from your desires for pleasure that war in your members?" (James 4: 1 nkjv)

All this does not mean that we must, when in debate with those who are heretics or who stubbornly resist a truth of the Bible, never speak boldly and "call a spade a spade," i.e. to speak the truth frankly, directly, and plainly, without beating around the bush or using polite euphemisms—even if the truth is harsh, uncomfortable, or unpleasant, and to not be "mealy-mouthed."  Paul spoke of the need to sharply rebuke certain opposers of biblical truth when engaging with them in debate, saying:

"Therefore I write these things being absent, lest being present I should use sharpness, according to the power which the Lord hath given me to edification, and not to destruction." (2 Cor. 13:10)

"This witness is true. Wherefore rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith." (Titus 1:13)

Notice that Paul's sharp (cutting) words are not intended to destroy an opponent, but to destroy his false reasoning and beliefs and thereby to build him up (edify). 

I don't believe that I have debated with others for the wrong reason or with the wrong motive, God being my witness. I recall years ago when I saw my error in believing that people were regenerated apart from hearing the gospel and before faith in it and the truth that sinners are born again by faith that I found myself being the target of hateful remarks from those Calvinists who believed that error. I was talking with Bob L. Ross of Pilgrim Publications, a Calvinist and lover of Spurgeon and one who fought with James White and others who held to that view, how I was being so treated and he said "welcome to the club." 

I also used to follow Kent Brandenburg's blog, a man who is an able minister of the gospel, and I made a comment about not believing the book of Esther was inspired and a minister named Thomas Ross, a KJV onlyist and Landmark Baptist, and he raked me over the coals for this and said I was going to Hell for denying Esther's inspiration. 

So, I don't think it is I who debates simply for the love of debating nor that I debate in a manner Christ would not approve. I think people say "you are a good debater" when they don't know how to refute my rebuttal of their views and saying this seems to be a way to stop the debate. I think people should simply say "you make some good points--please give me time to think them over and we will discuss them later."