It is constantly affirmed by those who teach that sinners are born again before faith (BABF) or regenerated before faith, that sinners are totally passive in being saved, born of God, or regenerated. But, as I will show, this is not true.
Birth may refer to the moment of conception, the beginning of a human zygote, or it may refer to the time when a fetus exits or is "delivered" from the womb. Which of these is the focus in the Bible, whether it be physical birth or the new birth of the Spirit? As we will see, it is birth from the womb which is most widely the biblical meaning.
"Now when Jesus was born in Bethlehem" (Matt. 2:1)
"born this day in the city of David" (Luke 2:11)
"born of women" (Matt. 11:11)
"born from their mother's womb" (Matt. 19:12)
But we do have the word "conceived" to sometimes denote becoming pregnant as in "he was conceived in the womb" (Luke 2:21). We also see that in the KJV how the word "conceived" is sometimes used of the act of a woman giving birth as in Romans 9:10 and the words "and when Rebecca had conceived by one." In Genesis 4:1 we read where "Adam knew Eve his wife; and she conceived, and bare Cain, and said, I have gotten a man from the LORD." In James 1:15 James speaks of being conceived before being "brought forth" in the birth, but seems to contemplate both aspects in being begotten. We also see this in the birth of Christ.
"And, behold, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bring forth a son, and shalt call his name JESUS... And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God." (Luke 1:311,35)
We also see where it is the man who "begets" for he is the one who produces the seed (Grk. sperma). But, it is the woman who gives birth. But, we also see where God is said to do both. The only exception to this is in the protoevangelium where the promised Messiah and Redeemer would be peculiarly "the seed of the woman," and is said because the Redeemer would be born of a virgin.
When the Bible talks about being "born again," or "born of God," or "begotten of God," or "born of the Spirit," are we to think of conception or the birth proper? Some have thought that spiritual birth is just like physical birth and involves conception, development in the womb, and birth from the mother's womb. They view conception as regeneration proper, the time when the divine seed (I Peter 1:23) is deposited in a sinner, and see the time following that as a time when the begotten sinner is under conviction of sin and in the womb of darkness, and see the time of delivery from the womb as corresponding to the time when the regenerated sinner is brought to faith and repentance or converted.
So, in this paradigm, there is both a father and a mother. If God or the Spirit is the Father (or sire), who is the mother? The old Hardshell Primitive Baptists held this view and I have often pointed this out to today's Hardshells and have asked them who is the mother? I get no answer. In the Bible the community of saints is viewed as the mother. In my post on the
"Children of Zion" (See
here) I write about this. Those who are born of God are also said to be born children of Zion. Paul spoke of a human being's creation by birth as being
"of the man" but
"by the woman." (I Cor. 11:11-12) I also cited these words from the Psalms:
"Glorious things are spoken of thee, O city of God. Selah. I will make mention of Rahab and Babylon to them that know me: behold Philistia, and Tyre, with Ethiopia; this man was born there. And of Zion it shall be said, This and that man was born in her: and the highest himself shall establish her. The LORD shall count, when he writes up the people, that this man was born there. Selah." (Psa. 87: 3-6)
"Let Israel rejoice in him that made him: let the children of Zion be joyful in their King." (Psa. 149: 2)
I also cited these words of the apostle Paul:
"But he who was of the bondwoman was born after the flesh; but he of the freewoman was by promise. Which things are an allegory: for these are the two covenants; the one from the mount Sinai, which genders to bondage, which is Agar. For this Agar is mount Sinai in Arabia, and answers to Jerusalem which now is, and is in bondage with her children. But Jerusalem which is above is free, which is the mother of us all." (Gal. 4: 23-26)
"Look unto Abraham your father, and unto Sarah that bare you: for I called him alone, and blessed him, and increased him. For the LORD shall comfort Zion" (Isa. 51: 2-3)
Since in spiritual birth believers have both a father and mother, we may say that the birth must involve the mother and that the focus is on birth from the womb and not on conception alone.
Are Sinners Only Passive in Being Born Again?
We know that the child or zygote that is conceived by the union of the male seed and the female egg is passive in that creation. But, it is not true that the child in the womb is totally passive in its birth from the womb. This is what medical science tells us. So, those of the BABF view who say that children are totally passive in being born are not correct. There is a lot of literature on this for those who want to research it. That research says that when a baby’s lungs are fully developed, the baby releases specific proteins into the amniotic fluid. These proteins signal the mother’s body that the baby is ready to breathe air, helping initiate the hormonal cascade that starts labor. Under normal conditions the baby naturally aligns the shoulders with the pelvic outlet so that they fit through the narrowest space more easily, and they rotate at key points in the pelvis, following the shape of the birth canal instead of forcing against it, finding the path of least resistance, guided by the mother's uterine contractions.
We know that babies are active in the womb. They can kick and move around. They respond to sound, to music, and to the voice of others, particularly the mother. In Genesis 25:22-26 and Hosea 12:3 we read of the twins Jacob and Esau who "struggled together" in the womb of Rebekah. Jacob even came out after having grabbed Esau by the heel. John the Baptist responded to Mary's salutation as heard by his mother Elizabeth and even "leaped for joy." (Luke 1:41) So, this was a case of a child being active prior to its birth and this makes it highly probable that the baby in the womb is also active in preparing itself for birth.
Jesus told Nicodemus - "you must be born again." (John 3:1-8) Nicodemus responds: "how can a man enter the second time into his mother's womb and be born?" This shows that Nicodemus understands "born" in the sense of coming out of the womb. He also implies that he understands that a man can do something to be born a second time. "How can a man enter..." Jesus implies this also when he says "you must be born again." Why would Jesus say this to him if telling him this was useless because he could do nothing towards being born again but must simply wait and see if the Spirit will give him this new birth? Further, Nicodemus asked Jesus - "how can these things be?" Jesus answered that the Spirit does the work and that it occurs as a result of making believers in Jesus. In verses 14-17 Jesus answers Nicodemus's question further by saying:
"And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have eternal life. For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved."
Jesus explains that it is by looking to Christ by faith that a person obtains eternal life through a birth of the Spirit. The bitten dying Israelites looked to the serpent on the pole and by looking they were kept from perishing and were given new life. So, by looking to Christ a person obtains life, by a birth and by believing. Notice these words:
"And the Lord said unto Moses, Make thee a fiery serpent, and set it upon a pole: and it shall come to pass, that everyone that is bitten, when he looketh upon it, shall live." (Num. 21:8 kjv)
Those who looked up on the serpent on the pole received a new life by that act, were in a sense reborn. In Jesus's answer to the question of Nicodemus -- "how can these things be?" -- Jesus first said that it is the result of the work of the Spirit and then said it is the result of believing in Christ. He says eternal life, or spiritual life, comes by being born again and by believing. That being so, the question then becomes whether believing is passive or active. That it is an action of the sinner there can be no doubt. Of course the action is the result of the power of the Spirit and the gospel, as we have seen. As I have said, it may be compared to a person who desperately needs a heart transplant in order to live and recognizes this fact and then asks a heart surgeon to perform the transplant. The patient acted in asking and yet was passive in the operation.
Charles Spurgeon in his commentary on John chapter three and on what Jesus was teaching Nicodemus said (Available to read
here; emphasis mine):
"Now, perhaps, some of you will be saying, “How are we to be saved? If there is no salvation without the new birth, how can we obtain the new birth?” Listen. The same chapter which tells you of the mystery of regeneration, tells you of the simple way of salvation by faith in Christ. John 3:14-15. And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of man be lifted up: that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have eternal life. “Whosoever.” If you believe in Christ, you are born again. If you trust him, you have the new life. This simple way of salvation is not contradictory to the way of salvation by the new birth, it is the same thing stated in a form that we can comprehend... There are two great truths revealed here; the one is, that we must be born again, and the other is, that whosoever believeth in Christ is saved. Sometimes those two truths seem to come into conflict with one another. A man says, “You say to me, ‘Only believe, and you shall be saved;’ and then, by-and-by, you tell me that I must be born again. Are both these statements true?” Yes, they are both true, and they are both in this chapter. We have been reading about the necessity of regeneration, now comes the glorious freeness of the gospel of Christ. You must be born into a new life if you are to be saved; how are you to have that great blessing? There is life for a look at Jesus Christ lifted up upon the cross, and lifted up in the preaching of the gospel. Look to him, then; and, as surely as those who were bitten by the serpents in the wilderness were healed the moment that they looked at the serpent of brass, so surely shall every son or daughter of Adam, who gives a faith-look at the crucified Saviour, be saved at once and for ever...There is no contradiction here to what we have been reading. He that believes in Christ receives the new birth, receives eternal life, and thus by faith, he gets that which is essential to a sight and entrance into the kingdom of God."
I believe that Spurgeon is "spot on" in these words. In explaining to Nicodemus how he can be born again and obtain life, spiritual and eternal life, he told him to believe in him as the Messiah and Son of God. This shows that being born again a sinner is both acted upon and is active.
Choosing to be Born?
I often hear those Calvinists of the BABF view argue that people do not choose to be born and so, they say, neither do they choose to be born again. But, in reply to this I say, first, that it is true that no person chooses to be born or created a physical human being, according to the Bible. But, to say that this means that spiritual birth is the same is jumping to conclusions. That is because the person being born again already exists, has already been born and created as a human being. So, it is possible therefore for a person who has been born once to desire to be born or created anew. Lots of people would love to be born a second time and live life over again so as not to make the same mistakes, for instance. How many times have I said, like others, that I wish that I could go back to such and such a time in my life and to have made a different choice? In fact, in today's world of advanced science, people are able to be cloned, and are working on ways to obtain all a person's memories from the brain and incorporate them into the new cloned body.
The same thing is often argued from the fact that not only do people not choose to be born but they also do not choose to be created or resurrected from the dead. But, we must not rely upon our human reasoning or what seems right or logical for our understanding of these mysteries. So Solomon said: "lean not upon your own understanding" (Prov. 3:5) and "there is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way of death." (Prov. 14:12) In reply to these arguments I have stated that we are not talking about someone who does not exist, who has not been created, who has never been born. We are talking about created people who desire to be newly created, to be, as it were, reborn, to obtain new life. In the Bible we see where David prayed for God to "create" in him a new heart. (Psalm 51:10) We also read where the apostle John said that spiritual life is obtained by believing in Christ. (John 20:31) In chapter fourteen I cited from Isaiah 51:1-3 where the Lord says "hear and your soul shall live." Jesus said that the spiritually dead first "hear the voice of the Son of God" and then are made alive by hearing. (John 5:25)
The apostle Peter said that people are "born again of incorruptible seed by the word of God which lives and abides forever." (I Peter 1:23) Abraham Booth (1734-1806), a leading 18th and 19th century Particular Baptist leader, rightly said:
"Regeneration must precede faith. This, though assumed as a certain fact:, may be justly doubted: for the page of inspiration does not warrant our supposing, that any one is born of God, before he believes in Jesus Christ; or, that regeneration is effected by the Holy Spirit, without the word of grace."
"But it is impossible for us to conceive of the mind being enlightened, of the conscience being relieved, of the will being regulated, and of the affections being purified by the word of truth, any further than it is believed. It may therefore be concluded, that regeneration is not, in order of time, prior to faith in Christ, and justification by him." ("Glad Tidings to Perishing Sinners," page 122)
If the word of God or gospel is a means to bring about the new birth, then it can hardly be a means until it is heard and believed, as Booth rightly stated. This argument is no doubt a reason why many of the BABF folks deny that the gospel or word of God is a means in regeneration. Peter is saying that people are born again by believing the word of God. So, the question is whether people choose to believe, whether coming to Jesus and believing in him are acts of the will.