Thursday, October 29, 2026

Reductio ad absurdum




Reductio ad absurdum is Latin for "reduction to the absurdity" and is a valid form of argument that disproves a statement or proposition by showing that accepting it leads to a logical contradiction, an impossibility, an absurdity, or a ridiculous outcome. It often leans on the "if, then" logical structure. The bible is full of such arguments. I believe that one of those examples of it in the Bible are in these words of the apostle Paul:

"For as touching those who were once enlightened and tasted of the heavenly gift, and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost, and tasted the good word of God, and the powers of the age to come, and then fell away, it is impossible to renew them again unto repentance; seeing they crucify to themselves the Son of God afresh, and put him to an open shame." (Heb. 6:6 esv) 

This passage has been hotly debated since Paul, who is commonly believed to have written Hebrews, wrote those words. Some say the passage clearly affirms that truly saved people can fall away, apostatize, so as to lose salvation and be forever damned. Others, deny this, some of whom say that the people described are not truly saved people, and some say, as I do, that Paul is arguing reductio ad absurdum, showing what the consequences would be if we assume, for the sake of argument, that saved people can lose salvation. Paul is describing a character that does not exist except in argument or supposition. This is done all the time in debate. For instance, I say to those who believe regeneration precedes faith - "you have a person who exists only theoretically, for there is no such person as a regenerated unbeliever." 

Those who believe that saved people can lose their salvation are often heard saying - "if you cannot lose your salvation, then you have a character who can commit the most abominable acts and still be saved." But, is there really such a character? Or, is he a hypothetical character? 

I chose the above translation from the English Standard Version because it, like some other translations, leaves out the word "if" in verse six. Some translations, such as the KJV, have "if they fall away." Though the "if" is not in the original, many believe that it is implied, and that is probably true. But, it really does not matter. The phrase begins with the participle kai parapesontas (καὶ παραπέσαντας), meaning "and having fallen away" or "and falling away." "If they shall fall away" was chosen by the KJV translators to treat the statement as a hypothetical condition, and indeed it is such, although that is discernible apart from adding the word "if." 

In debate it is a common practice to use hypotheticals, suppositions, "what if" scenarios, or "if, then" type of reasonings in logic. When debating whether a saved person can lose his or her salvation, oftentimes these tactics are used. One side will argue - "if a saved person could lose his salvation, then" such and such absurdity would ensue. On the other side one will argue - "if a saved person cannot lose his salvation, then" such and such absurdity would ensue. In such discussions a debater may say "if we agree for the sake of argument..." The speaker says: "If [X] is true—and let us assume for the moment that it is—then [Y] follows." 

Here is another example similar to the text in Hebrews:

"Had Jesus fulfilled every prophecy concerning the Messiah and was not born in Bethlehem he could not possibly be the Messiah."

Here are other examples:

"For concerning God who is immutably good and cannot lie, and who changed and told a lie, it is impossible for him to return to being immutably good and honest." 

In each case there is no such character. The kind of God described is only a hypothetical being and the argument is an example of reduction ad absurdum. In discussions about the nature and attributes of God we might ponder many different scenarios, such as affirming that "God is love, just, holy, omnipotent, and mutable, not knowing the future choices of free will creatures" (which statement is the case with those who believe in Process Theology or Open Theism). Such a god does not exist, but is completely hypothetical. Another example of a hypothetical is seen in this sentence:

"As concerning those who have been promised and given eternal life and eternally died, it would be impossible for God to be trusted to keep his word and would be a contradiction."

We could also say - "whoever has the only key and loses it, will never unlock the door." 

Similar Sentences With The "if"or
Biblical Examples of Reductio Ad Absurdum

"But if there is no resurrection of the dead, then Christ is not risen. And if Christ is not risen, then our preaching is empty and your faith is also empty...For if the dead do not rise, then Christ is not risen. And if Christ is not risen, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins! Then also those who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished." (I Cor. 15: 13-14, 16-17 nkjv) 

In this line of argument by the apostle Paul he is showing the absurd consequences that are entailed in denying the resurrection of Christ. 

In Luke 7:39 Simon the Pharisee thought to himself: “If this man were a prophet, he would know what kind of woman is touching him. She's a sinner!” 

So, in conclusion I say that Paul is using a hypothetical case in the passage in Hebrews chapter six. He is showing how absurd the consequences would be if indeed a truly saved person lost his salvation. I believe this interpretation is sustained by the context. 

First, in verse three Paul says: "let us go on to perfection" and then says "And this we will do if God permits." Here Paul says that he is certain that those who have truly been saved will indeed go on to perfection because it is God's will. Second, he also tells the Hebrews, who he believes are for the most part truly the children of God, "we are confident of better things concerning you, yes, things that accompany salvation." Third, if it is a case that really happens, then no one who lost salvation could be saved again or restored.

There are some who believe in eternal security and the impossibility of a born again child of God to be eternally doomed who explain this passage by saying that the description of the ones who supposedly fall away may be describing false professors who were never truly saved. However, I find that explanation untenable. I wrote against this view in this post (here). I cited Charles Spurgeon who said the following:

"First, then, we answer the question, WHO ARE THE PEOPLE HERE SPOKEN OF? If you read Dr. Gill, Dr. Owen, and almost all the eminent Calvinistic writers, they all of them assert that these persons are not Christians. They say, that enough is said here to represent a man who is a Christian externally, but not enough to give the portrait of a true believer. Now, it strikes me they would not have said this if they had had some doctrine to uphold; for a child, reading this passage, would say, that the persons intended by it must be Christians. If the Holy Spirit intended to describe Christians, I do not see that he could have used more explicit terms than there are here. How can a man be said to be enlightened, and to taste of the heavenly gift, and to be made partaker of the Holy Ghost, without being a child of God? With all deference to these learned doctors, and I admire and love them all, I humbly conceive that they allowed their judgments to be a little warped when they said that; and I think I shall be able to show that none but true believers are here described."

That is my view exactly. Spurgeon said:

"But some one says, "What is falling away?" Well, there never has been a case of it yet, and therefore I cannot describe it from observation; but I will tell you what I suppose it is. To fall away, would be for the Holy Spirit entirely to go out of a man—for his grace entirely to cease; not to lie dormant, but to cease to be—for God, who has begun a good work, to leave off doing it entirely—to take his hand completely and entirely away, and say, "There, man! I have half saved thee; now I will damn thee." That is what falling away is." 

If the six experiences of saved people (as Spurgeon showed in the sermon) do not keep a man saved, then he can never be saved. 

No comments: