Prevenient Grace (4)

Common operations of the Spirit, for Puritans, refer to the Holy Spirit's temporary or superficial work on the hearts of unregenerate people. Unlike special saving grace, these operations restrain sin, convict conscience, enlighten the mind, and enable superficial obedience. They are often preparatory, bringing sinners to fear punishment or experience emotional, non-saving convictions. These common operations may easily be called common or prevenient grace. Puritans emphasized that these operations do not regenerate nor save. A person might experience them, such as fearing hell or conviction of sin, and feeling deep guilt, and yet remain unregenerate. 

The Spirit may enlighten the mind of an unbeliever to understand many truths of Scripture and even produce "pangs of conscience" and yet he remains aloof from Christ. Puritan preachers often described these as "beginnings of compunction" or a "ministry of the law," which can lead a person to seek God, even if they do not lead to actual salvation.

God’s Word teaches the doctrine of irresistible grace, but it also teaches that there is resistible grace, as we have previously stated. It teaches that there is common grace and special grace that is always effectual. It teaches that there are degrees of grace (Eph. 4: 7; etc.), and that some effects require abundance of grace. (Rom. 5: 17) Regarding these things we will have more to say, but first let us return to reviewing things the Puritan Calvinist John Owen wrote on this subject.

In "Conviction of Sin Before Conversion" by John Owen under "Several Practical Cases of Conscience Resolved" (Available here), Discourse One, page four, wrote (emphasis mine):

"QUESTION. To what extent should I be convicted of my sin and guilt before I may turn to Jesus Christ to find salvation?"

For, seeing conviction is so indispensably necessary, some may say, "It hath not been thus and thus with me,—according as hath been declared." Therefore, I would only show what I judge to be so necessary, as that without it a soul cannot be supposed sincerely to have closed with Christ. And we having all made our profession of choosing and closing with Christ, as I would be loath to say any thing that might discourage any, lest they should have failed in the very necessary work of conviction; so I would not betray the truth of God, nor the souls of any."

By the words "closed with Christ" he means the result of all these preparatory works of God which is the salvation of the soul. Many of the authors of the 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith spoke of sinners "closing with Christ." It denotes the time when the sinner and Christ covenant with each other, as in a marriage union, and when they become one. It is when the convicted sinner is fully drawn to Christ and surrenders all to him. Notice also how Owen speaks of the "very necessary work of conviction." This is of course an example of prevenient grace. We need to be careful, however, of going to extremes in regard to this. 

Very young children may truly come to Christ and be saved even though they have not felt severe pangs of conscience over sin as have adults who have spent years in sin. We must also keep in mind that even in conviction there is some degree of faith, for there is belief that one is a sinner before God. But, this faith is not yet saving faith for it has not yet fixed itself on Christ and his atoning blood, there being not yet "faith in his blood" for "propitiation." (Rom. 3:25) Remember that "even the demons believe and tremble" and yet are not saved. (James 2: 19) One said to Jesus "I know who you are--the Holy One of God." (Mark 1: 24) There are those shallow superficial believers described in the parable of the soils who "believed for awhile and then fell away" when trials and persecution come because they "have no root in themselves." (Luke 8: 13) Their faith is not sincere nor genuine. 

Owen wrote further:

"Therefore, I shall place it upon this: What Jesus Christ doth indispensably call men unto, in order to believing in him, that is indispensably required of them. And this I shall manifest out of two or three places of Scripture:—Mark 2:17, "I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance." Now, this calling them unto repentance, is a calling them unto it by the faith which is in him...What is the conclusion? "Lost sinners," saith Christ, "this is that I require of you." So that this is what I assert to be indispensably necessary,—namely, that they are so far convinced that they are sinners as to state and course, that they are not righteous in themselves, and can have no righteousness in themselves. I say, therefore, when a person is not really convinced that he is not righteous, he is not under the call of Jesus Christ; and if he doth believe this, he is under a sovereign dispensation, and let not such despond."

On this point we have already spoken in the previous chapter. This conviction that a person is a justly condemned sinner is the result of the working of both the Father and the Spirit. It is the result of the Father's teaching and drawing, as Jesus said: "everyone who has heard and learned from the Father comes to me" (John 6: 45); And of the Holy Spirit he said, "And when He has come, He will convict the world of sin, and of righteousness, and of judgment: of sin, because they do not believe in Me; of righteousness, because I go to My Father and you see Me no more; of judgment, because the ruler of this world is judged." (John 16: 8-11 nkjv) Whether all are drawn by the Father, or only the elect, is a question we will address later, along with the question as to when a person is born again, whether it was when drawn and taught, or afterward when he comes to Christ. The point now is to show that there are things that God does in the hearts and minds of lost sinners before they are given spiritual life out of spiritual death. 

Owen continued:

"Another direction of Christ is, “They that be whole need not a physician, but they that are sick,” Matt. ix. 12...Now, these things I do account indispensably necessary, antecedently to believing, as to the substance of them. And this, I hope, hath been found in all our souls. And if we have obtained so far, we need not then question whether our closing with Christ be sincere or not. This is all that I dare assert to be absolutely and indispensably necessary. Many pretend to believe, though they never were convinced thoroughly that they were not righteous, — never were sick in their lives, — never had fears that they should die. These are contrary to the express rule Christ hath given, “I came not to call the righteous, but sinners;” — not those that say, “There is hope,” but those that say, “There is no hope.""

As we have said, being awakened nearly always precedes being saved or born again. Further, as we will see, some enlightenment is also experienced in this awakening.

In "The Spirit’s Work of Conviction through the Conscience of a Sinner" (See here) Owen wrote:

"The work of conviction of sin on those who expected it not, who desired it not, and who would avoid it if by any means possible they could. The world is filled with instances of this nature. While men have been full of love to their sins, at peace in them, enjoying benefit and advantage by them, the word coming upon them in its power has awed, disquieted, and terrified them, taken away their peace, destroyed their hopes, and made them, as it were, whether they would or not—that is, contrary to their desires, inclinations, and carnal affections—to conclude that if they comply not with what is proposed unto them in that word, which before they took no notice of nor had any regard unto, they must be presently or eternally miserable."

As a Calvinist I have, in my discussions with Arminians and Pelagians about "free will" and "irresistible grace," mentioned that God convicts sinners of their sinful and condemned state without the sinner's permission or choice. I have pointed this out because of the objection that says "God does not force or compel anyone to believe or convert." I ask them -- "does God force or compel people when convincing them of sin?" Of course, God does not force in one sense, meaning he does not compel a sinner apart from making the sinner willing. Owen, in the above words, mentions the fact that God convicts sinners of sin even when they did not expect it nor desired it. This happened in the case of the apostle Paul on the Damascus road. He was forced to acknowledge that Christ was indeed the Messiah and Son of God. Further, in the day of judgment "every knee shall bow and every tongue confess that Jesus is Lord" and this is because they are forced or compelled to do so. (Rom. 14: 11; Phil. 2: 10-11)

That people may experience conviction of sin and yet remain degenerate is seen in several cases in the bible. However, let us notice a couple of them.

The case of Felix

"And after certain days, when Felix came with his wife Drusilla, which was a Jewess, he sent for Paul, and heard him concerning the faith in Christ. And as he reasoned of righteousness, temperance, and judgment to come, Felix trembled, and answered, Go thy way for this time; when I have a convenient season, I will call for thee." (Acts 24: 24-25 kjv)

Felix was a very wicked man and never became a Christian. Yet, under the powerful preaching of the apostle Paul about the "judgment to come" this king was made to fear and tremble. We see how the gospel is "the power of God unto salvation." By this power Felix was made to fear being judged for his lack of righteousness. Felix, for a moment, experienced an awakening, and the thought that what Paul was saying may be true. However, as Jesus taught in the parable of the soils and seed, the seed of truth fell on wayside ground so that the birds of the air (symbolizing Satan) came and devoured the seed. ("Those by the wayside are the ones who hear; then the devil comes and takes away the word out of their hearts, lest they should believe and be saved"; Luke 8: 12 nkjv) This is what happened to Felix. Still, it was a fact that God was gracious to Felix in having the seed of the gospel broadcast to his heart and mind and given an opportunity to be saved. 

Felix trembling from fear of diving judgment was no evidence of salvation as many of the Hardshell Baptists teach. The demons believe in God's existence and tremble with fear. (James 2: 19) Wrote Isaiah: "The sinners in Zion are afraid; Fearfulness has seized the hypocrites: “Who among us shall dwell with the devouring fire? Who among us shall dwell with everlasting burnings?” (Isa. 33: 14 nkjv) Even lost sinners when under conviction of sin may realize that "It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God." (He. 10: 31) Sadly, however, these thoughts are quickly pushed out of the mind and never lead to repentance. 

Some preachers, especially some Calvinists, believe that it is wrong to "hell scare" sinners into a decision for Christ. However, that is unbiblical. In fact, I wish more lost and hardened sinners were even more afraid of coming judgment. So too did the apostle Paul who wrote:

"For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, that each one may receive the things done in the body, according to what he has done, whether good or bad. Knowing, therefore, the terror of the Lord, we persuade men..." (II Cor. 5: 10-11 nkjv)

On this text Spurgeon said the following in his sermon (See here) on the text "persuading them concerning Jesus" (Acts 28: 23):

"But are we right trying to persuade men? Are not human hearts too hard to be broken by so feeble a hammer as our persuasion? Yes, I most solemnly believe they are: but that is not the question. “What is the use of persuading them, if you know that they will not be won by your persuasion in and of itself?” Well, brethren, I feel safe in doing what Paul did. I will not stop to solve difficulties, but merely say, Paul persuaded, and so will I. “Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord, we persuade men.” “Oh,” says one, “we may persuade awakened sinners, but not dead sinners!” But I reply that Paul persuaded these chief men of the Jews, some of whom never believed in Jesus, for their hearts were gross, and their eyes were blinded. Paul persuaded them, though they were judicially blinded. He knew that they were living men, and that they were possessed of reason, even though they had no grace; and so he appealed to what remained in them, and he persuaded them. Again I say, I will do what Paul did. But I know, as Paul also knew, that all the human persuasion in the world will fall short of the mark without divine power. I never dreamed that my persuasion was of the slightest avail without the Holy Ghost." (emphasis mine)

Dr. Barnes in his commentary wrote:

"We persuade men - We endeavor to persuade them to flee from the wrath to come; to be prepared to stand before the judgment-seat, and to be suited to enter into heaven. Observe here the uniqueness of the statement. It is not, we drive people; or we endeavor to alarm people; or we frighten people; or we appeal merely to their fears, but it is, we persuade people, we endeavor to induce them by all the arts of persuasion and argument to flee from the wrath to come. The future judgment, and the scenes of future woe, are not proper topics for mere declamation. To declaim constantly on hell-fire and perdition; to appeal merely to the fears of people, is not the way in which Paul and the Saviour preached the gospel. The knowledge that there would be a judgment, and that the wicked would be sent to hell, was a powerful motive for Paul to endeavor to "persuade" people to escape from wrath, and was a motive for the Saviour to weep over Jerusalem, and to lament its folly, and its doom; Luke 19:41. But they who fill their sermons with the denunciations of wrath; who dwell on the words "hell" and "damnation," for the purpose of rhetoric or declamation, to round a period, or merely to excite alarm; and who "deal damnation around the land" as if they rejoiced that people were to be condemned, and in a tone and manner as if they would be pleased to execute it, have yet to learn the true nature of the way to win people to God, and the proper effect of those awful truths on the mind."

I can agree with what Barnes here says but would call attention to his frequent use of the word "mere" or "merely." I also agree that there is a way to provoke or teach people to fear the Lord (Psalm 34: 11), which is a good thing, yea "the beginning of wisdom" (Prov. 9: 10), but that it may be done in the wrong way and in a wrong spirit. However, that does not mean that it is always wrong for preachers to put people in fear of coming judgment. I am sure that this is what the apostle Paul means in the above text. Further, what is wrong with sounding the alarm to sinners in view of coming judgment? So we read such verses as this:

"Blow the trumpet in Zion, And sound an alarm in My holy mountain! Let all the inhabitants of the land tremble; For the day of the LORD is coming, For it is at hand." (Joel 2: 1 nkjv)

Noah, when being warned about the coming judgment of God upon the world, was "moved with fear" and acted to build the ark as God commanded. (Heb. 11: 7) So sinners should be moved with fear of coming judgment and turn to God and "flee from the wrath to come." (Matt. 3: 7)

Spurgeon in a sermon on Felix (1858) said:

"But I take it that conscience of itself is so thoroughly corrupt, together with all the other powers of manhood, that it would never even make a man go so far as trembling, if there were not something at work upon the conscience, besides being left to its own natural force. My brethren, I believe that what some people call natural conviction is, after all, the work of the Spirit. Some very profound divines are so fond of the doctrine that the Holy Spirit always works efficaciously, that they think that the Spirit never can work a transitory emotion in a man’s soul; they impute such things to conscience. And if they see a man like Felix trembling, they say ’tis all natural conscience! Now, do they not see that they are in this touching on another doctrine equally dear to them—the doctrine of total depravity?—for if men be totally depraved by nature, then as trembling is a good thing, they are not capable even of that without some influence of the Holy Spirit. The fact is, my hearers, the Holy Spirit works in two ways. In some men’s hearts he works with restraining Grace only, and the restraining Grace, though it will not save them, is enough to keep them from breaking out into the open and corrupt vices in which some men indulge who are totally left by the restraints of the Spirit. Now, there was in Felix some little portion of this restraining Grace; and when the Apostle laid the Gospel open to him, this restraining Grace quickened the conscience, and compelled Felix to tremble. Mark you, this Grace man may resist and does resist; for albeit that the Holy Spirit is Omnipotent and never can be resisted when he works Omnipotently, yet as a strong man may sometimes not put out all his strength, but work with his finger, for instance, so that he may permit even a gnat or an ant to overcome him, even so the Holy Spirit sometimes works but temporarily and but for good and excellent purposes, which he always accomplishes; but he allows men to quench and resist his influences, so that salvation is not so much as approached thereby. God the Holy Spirit may work in men some good desires and feelings, and yet have no design of saving them. But mark, none of these feelings are things that accompany sure salvation, for if so, they would be continued. But he does not work Omnipotently to save, except in the persons of his own elect, whom he assuredly bringeth to himself. I believe, then, that the trembling of Felix is to be accounted for by the restraining grace of the Spirit quickening his conscience and making him tremble." (See here)

These are excellent observations of Spurgeon and I agree with them completely. They are examples of how prevenient grace is at work in the hearts of both elect and non-elect and that in the case of the former it will always bring salvation, but in the latter will not. 

The case of Agrippa

"Now as he thus made his defense, Festus said with a loud voice, “Paul, you are beside yourself! Much learning is driving you mad!” But he said, “I am not mad, most noble Festus, but speak the words of truth and reason. For the king, before whom I also speak freely, knows these things; for I am convinced that none of these things escapes his attention, since this thing was not done in a corner. King Agrippa, do you believe the prophets? I know that you do believe.” Then Agrippa said to Paul, “You almost persuade me to become a Christian.” (Acts 26: 24-28 nkjv)

Agrippa was experiencing some working of God upon his heart and mind, some aspect of prevenient grace, when he was almost persuaded. It was an act of grace that Agrippa was sent a messenger by God and that he was being persuaded by such a messenger. It was also a good thing that he had in some measure a willingness to give Paul a fair hearing. It is also good that he was positively affected to some degree.